You're Wasting Serious Money On Fake SEO For Your Mid-Market Brand
    Back to Articles
    Industry Insights

    You're Wasting Serious Money On Fake SEO For Your Mid-Market Brand

    Michael McDougald
    July 11, 2025

    I've built and ranked sites that pushed $10-million in sales and put dull products like commercial doors and bathroom stalls—on Slate and The Wall Street Journal.

    Trust me: "budget" backlinks your current agency gets each month are reputation grenades disguised as bargains. Links tell a story of trust and authority like a watch signals status. Why flex a fake watch when you have a Ferrari in the garage? You can do better.

    If Your SEO Agency Ignored That Shiny New Award, Fire Them

    Last quarter a former employer snagged a spot on Nashville's Top 25 Fastest Growing Companies by Nashville Business Journal. Their agency or team have yet to try and coax a backlink from the awarding body's highly trusted domain. That's PR malpractice.

    Quick win: Write a 90-word blurb for the award committee; 9 times out of 10, they'll paste it verbatim—link and all.

    But They're Getting You Links With "Good Numbers" Right?

    Your agency's monthly report brags, "We landed 5 DR-60 links!" Cool story. DR is an educated guess—not gospel. Even worse, the traffic those sites boast often comes from bots, adult queries, or AI-generated clickbait.

    DR is sold by the street merchants of SEO.

    The Fall Enslaves Us All – The Rise of Link-Spam Penalties

    Google finally called time-out. The June 2024 Link-Spam Update hammered roundup posts, exact-match anchors, and "high-DR, zero-trust" sites in one sweep.

    Translation: at best Google ignores those links; at worst it drags your whole domain into algorithmic purgatory.

    What Your Agency Isn't Doing (But Charges You For Anyway)

    • ❌ Leaving awards on the table – zero outreach for backlink-ready wins
    • ❌ Failing to interview your subject-matter experts
    • ❌ Skipping vendor and partner pages
    • ❌ Ghosting HARO / Help a B2B Reporter
    • ❌ Ignoring data journalism
    • ❌ Reporting DR like revenue – vanity metrics over verifiable trust

    Digital PR Moves They Forgot Existed

    • Data-driven reports – commission original research; journalists need fresh numbers
    • Interactive assets – calculators, visualizations, quizzes that earn embeds
    • Conference newsjacking – piggy-back announcements on industry events
    • Expert commentary blitzes – 48-hour turnaround quotes for breaking news

    Final Rant

    If diaper-coupon blogs and DR-inflation gimmicks felt "good enough," you wouldn't still be reading. Your middle-market e-commerce or B2B brand is one sharp, creative campaign away from elite authority IF you quit measuring success in vanity metrics and start demanding trust.

    MM

    Michael McDougald

    Founder of Right Thing SEO, a math-driven SEO agency based in Nashville and Sarasota. Michael has spent 15+ years helping businesses achieve sustainable organic growth through data-driven strategies.

    Learn more about Michael →

    Ready to Stop the Fall?

    Get a free SEO assessment and discover what's holding your site back.